746 S Fred Shuttlesworth Cir, Cincinnati, OH 45229

Price: $259,900

Price: $183,995

746 S Fred Shuttlesworth Cir

Cincinnati, OH 45229

Price: $259,900

Price: $183,995

746 S Fred Shuttlesworth Cir

Cincinnati, OH 45229

North Avondale Neighborhood

Rehab Needed: $175,000-$200,000

ARV: $789,000

Watch The Following 4 Walkthrough Videos!

Price = $183,995

Bedrooms: 9

Bathrooms: 3:2

Stories: 2.5

Basement: Full/Partial Finish

Square Feet: 4,385

Lot Size: 0.35 Acre

Year Built: 1904

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Click "street address", insert "746" into left house # range field, insert "fred" into street name, click search

For sale is a historic brick mansion located in the sought-after neighborhood of North Avondale in Cincinnati. This 2.5-story property, built in 1904, stands on a 0.35-acre lot and boasts a substantial living area of 4,385 square feet. The house comprises nine bedrooms, three full bathrooms, and two half bathrooms, along with a full, partially finished basement. A notable feature is the large, raised curved ceiling covered porch.

Inside, the main floor is characterized by very high ceilings. Unique to its historical design, the house includes two staircases, with separate staff quarters and stairwell, a butler's pantry, a dumbwaiter, multiple fireplaces, and ornate trim and finishes both inside and out. The mansion is adorned with many stained glass windows and has recently been updated with a new 3-dimensional asphalt roof.

Flooring throughout the house is predominantly hardwood, including some areas with parquet. The heating is provided by an old gas boiler system. A critical note for potential investors is the presence of lead paint; however, the City of Cincinnati is responsible for funding the lead paint abatement for this historic property.

The mansion requires extensive rehabilitation, including but not limited to, painting or repairing all exterior trim, plaster and/or drywall repair, debris removal, new carpet installation, and overall restoration to bring it back to its original glory.

Link to Cincinnati Preservation Association Endangered Building Fund

Photos of the property

Comps Avg. Price Per SQ.FT (PPSF): $180.82

Comparable Sales

Comp 1

Address: 3997 Beechwood Ave

Sales Price: $1,005,012

Sales Date: 5/30/2023

Distance Away: 0.42 Mile

Square Footage: 5,201

Year Built: 1910

Bed/Bath: 6 / 3:1

Basement: Full/Partial Finish

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.40 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $193.23

Comp 2

Address: 952 Marion Ave

Sales Price: $720,000

Sales Date: 9/20/2023

Distance Away: 0.36 Mile

Square Footage: 3,911

Year Built: 1909

Bed/Bath: 5 / 3:2

Basement: Full/Unfinished

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.39 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $184.10

Comp 3

Address: 4015 Beechwood Ave

Sales Price: $635,000

Sales Date: 11/20/2023

Distance Away: 0.45 Mile

Square Footage: 3,600

Year Built: 1915

Bed/Bath: 5 / 3:1

Basement: Partial/Unfinished

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.35 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $176.07

Comp 4

Address: 718 Clinton Springs Ave

Sales Price: $800,000

Sales Date: 10/13/2023

Distance Away: 0.30 Mile

Square Footage: 5,184

Year Built: 1918

Bed/Bath: 5 / 3:1

Basement: Full/Unfinished

Garage: 3 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.41 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $154.32

Comp 5

Address: 3940 Red Bud Ave

Sales Price: $655,000

Sales Date: 7/10/2023

Distance Away: 0.38 Mile

Square Footage: 4,200

Year Built: 1923

Bed/Bath: 6 / 3:1

Basement: Full/Finished

Garage: 1 Car Attached

Lot Size: 0.26 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $155.95

Comp 6

Address: 3848 Dakota Ave

Sales Price: $1,200,000

Sales Date: ACTIVE LISTING

Distance Away: 0.47 Mile

Square Footage: 3,910

Year Built: 1906

Bed/Bath: 7 / 3:2

Basement: Full/Unfinished

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.49 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $306.91

Comp 7

Address: 3997 Beechwood Ave

Sales Price: $599,000

Sales Date: ACTIVE LISTING

Distance Away: 0.33 Mile

Square Footage: 3,598

Year Built: 1896

Bed/Bath: 5 / 3:1

Basement: Full/Unfinished

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.36 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $166.48

Comp 8

Address: 938 Lenox Pl

Sales Price: $711,000

Sales Date: SALE PENDING

Distance Away: 0.42 Mile

Square Footage: 5,163

Year Built: 1902

Bed/Bath: 7 / 3:1

Basement: Full/Partial Finish

Garage: NONE

Lot Size: 0.37 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $137.71

Comp 9

Address: 245 Wedgewood Ave

Sales Price: $415,000

Sales Date: SALE PENDING

Distance Away: 0.53 Mile

Square Footage: 2,719

Year Built: 1910

Bed/Bath: 4 / 2:1

Basement: Partial/Unfinished

Garage: 2 Car Detached

Lot Size: 0.17 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT: $152.63

Comps Average Price Per SQ.FT (PPSF): $180.82

Comparable Sales

Comp 1

Comp 2

Comp 3

Address

3997 Beechwood Ave

952 Marion Ave

4015 Beechwood Ave

Sales Price

$1,005,012

$720,000

$635,000

Sales Date

5/30/2023

9/20/2023

11/20/2023

Distance Away

0.42 Mile

0.36 Mile

0.45 Mile

Square Feet

5,201

3,911

3,600

Year Built

1910

1909

Beds/Bath

6/3:1

5/3:2

5/3:1

Basement

Full/Partial Finish

Full/Unfinished

Full/Partial Finish

Garage

2 Car Detached

2 Car Detached

2 Car Detached

Lot Size

0.40 Acre

0.39 Acre

0.35 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT.

$193.23

$184.10

$176.07

Additional Comparables

Comp 4

Comp 5

Comp 6

Address

718 Clinton Springs Ave

3940 Red Bud Ave

3848 Dakota Ave

Sales Price

$800,000

$655,000

$1,200,000

Sales Date

10/13/2023

7/10/2023

ACTIVE LISTING

Distance Away

0.30 Mile

0.38 Mile

0.47 Mile

Square Feet

5,184

4,200

3,910

Year Built

1918

1923

1906

Beds/Bath

5/3:1

6/3:1

7/3:2

Basement

Full/Unfinished

Full/Finished

Full/Finished

Garage

3 Car Detached

1 Car Attached

2 Car Detached

Lot Size

0.41 Acre

0.26 Acre

0.49 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT.

$154.32

$155.95

$306.91

Additional Comparables

Comp 7

Comp 8

Comp 9

Address

3924 Rose Hill Ave

938 Lenox Pl

245 Wedgewood Ave

Sales Price

$599,000

$711,000

$415,000

Sales Date

ACTIVE LISTING

SALE PENDING

SALE PENDING

Distance Away

0.33 Mile

0.42 Mile

0.53 Mile

Square Feet

3,598

5,163

2,719

Year Built

1896

1902

1910

Beds/Bath

5/3:1

7/3:1

4/2:1

Basement

Full/Unfinished

Full/Partial Finish

Partial/Unfinished

Garage

2 Car Detached

NONE

2 Car Detached

Lot Size

0.36 Acre

0.37 Acre

0.17 Acre

Price Per SQ.FT.

$166.48

$137.71

$152.63

746 S Fred Shuttlesworth Cir, Cincinnati, OH 45229, USA

Comps to support ARV

Comp 1

Comp 2

Comp 3

Address

154 N Woodward Ave

830 Upland Ave

23 Upper Ave

Sales Price

$63,000

$95,000

$82,500

Sales Date

10/21/2022

08/02/2022

9/27/2022

Distance Away

0.4 Miles

.99 Miles

0.7 Miles

Square Feet

1,280

1,568

1,320

Year Built

1905

1948

1930

Beds/Bath

3/1.0

4/2

3/1

Comps to support ARV

Comp 1

Address: 154 N Woodward Ave

Sales Price: $63,000

Sales Date: 10/21/22

Distance Away: 0.4 Miles

Square Footage: 1,280

Year Built: 1905

Bed/Bath: 3 / 1.0

Comp 2

Address: 830 Upland Ave

Sales Price: $95,000

Sales Date: 8/2/22

Distance Away: .99 Miles

Square Footage: 1,568

Year Built: 1948

Bed/Bath: 4 / 2

Comp 3

Address: 23 Upper Ave

Sales Price: $82,500

Sales Date: 9/27/2022

Distance Away: 0.7 Miles

Square Footage: 1,320

Year Built: 1930

Bed/Bath: 3/1